Elk River Cruise
Posted: Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:35 pm
Discussions relating to the MacGregor line of trailerable sailboats
https://www.macgregorsailors.com/forum/
https://www.macgregorsailors.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=29756
kingtoros wrote: ↑Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:35 pm A fine Sunday with low winds and mild healing on the Elk Neck River area of the Chesapeake.
Departing from Rogue's Harbor we had some mild winds to start ending with some strong gusts just barely getting to 40 degree heels. What a great boat this 2005is, there was even some time for drone stills:
![]()
That looks like a great spot to play in. Did you head up into the river or out toward the lighthouse?kingtoros wrote: ↑Sun Oct 01, 2023 9:35 pm A fine Sunday with low winds and mild healing on the Elk Neck River area of the Chesapeake.
Departing from Rogue's Harbor we had some mild winds to start ending with some strong gusts just barely getting to 40 degree heels. What a great boat this 2005is, there was even some time for drone stills:
![]()
I'm guessing you were testing out my last data point.The wind was not as strong today but it was steady so I was able to experiment with how much heel is useful and how much is just a waste of wind.
The boat is very tender until the ballast tanks are above the water line. After that the boat it firms up and is very predictable. I could easily hold anywhere from 15 to 45 degrees at will. Here’s what I determined:
- 0-15 degrees the boat is very tender and most of the power seems to go into filling the sails and causing the boat to heel. Around 15 degrees it begins to move.
- 15-25 degrees seems to be the sweet spot with 20 probably being the best. Every increase in wind speed turns into a proportional increase in boat speed. I’d estimate that we were doing between 1/4 and 1/3 of the wind speed on a beam reach and between 1/3 and 1/2 of wind speed on a broad reach.
- 25-35 degrees is a waste of wind. If I allow the boat to continue to heel it does not go any faster. If anything it seemed to slow the boat down the more I allow it to heel. I don’t have any actual measurements. I was too busy with the main sheet to spend much time reading the instruments.
- Above 35 degrees hurts my ears. The crew yells too much and things fall off other things in the cabin. It is fun but in no way is it efficient.
I wish it was something more than a main sail and a jib. Odd angle for the shot I suppose, but it was too pretty not to sharedlandersson wrote: ↑Mon Oct 02, 2023 3:48 am Nice post. I really enjoy deploying my asymmetrical spinnker when I can.![]()
I mostly go down river, yes for the light house and deeper water. It's definitely a nice area, and reasonably close to home.
I remember this post! Yes, it was 100% intentional, we were trying to see just how far we could heel. Even at 40 degrees there was no indication we were going in. And ... it was at the crew's requestBe Free wrote: ↑Mon Oct 02, 2023 8:30 am Just curious, were you trying to heel the boat that much for the just for the fun of it? We had a discussion about this almost exactly a year ago. For the benefit of those who did not follow the original, this is from my log of one of my first sails on my.
I'm guessing you were testing out my last data point.![]()
I concur, almost
I have been meaning to ask about this cruise! I don't recall seeing a trip report
Be Free wrote: ↑Mon Oct 02, 2023 5:39 pm I wasn't doing it on purpose. I got caught in a very short duration wind event. It laid the boat on it's side and spun it around in a tight circle. I doubt if it lasted a full minute but it seemed like forever. The damage I did to my right shoulder trying to release the jib sheets took almost a year to heal. Like I said, not fun.
I didn’t post oneI have been meaning to ask about this cruise! I don't recall seeing a trip report
But the good news is that there was no damage to the boat and the ballast brought it right back up as soon as the wind let up. There were a few things to pick up in the cabin but nothing broken. These boats are incredibly tough.kingtoros wrote: ↑Tue Oct 03, 2023 7:43 pmBe Free wrote: ↑Mon Oct 02, 2023 5:39 pm I wasn't doing it on purpose. I got caught in a very short duration wind event. It laid the boat on it's side and spun it around in a tight circle. I doubt if it lasted a full minute but it seemed like forever. The damage I did to my right shoulder trying to release the jib sheets took almost a year to heal. Like I said, not fun.This made me gulp...
NiceAft wrote: ↑Tue Oct 03, 2023 11:33 pm We were going to do it last summer, but my wife fell from a ladder trying to get into the cockpit and fractured her right shoulder blade; three ribs, and two places on her pubic bone. That took care of those plans. Three days in the hospital and three and a half weeks at a rehabilitation facility. Maybe 2024![]()
I have been telling all my friends about this and your "wind event." We conclude, cyclone.
շնորհակալություն. շատ բարի քո կողմից:Armenians have a saying "antsats ullah" translating to "may it be in your past." The sentiment is that I hope she is better and it is only a memory.