Everyone is a newbie once. I'll come to you when I want to learn to fly and ask questions.
You are right, the Mac doesn't sail well and doesn't motor that fast. I've owned a Hunter34 and a 20' runabout, the Mac doesn't do either well.
Those ass-hats at sailinganarchy love to bash the Mac, it's sport for them. Most who bash the Mac are boatless racing fanatics or rich Newport snobs, people I have no desire to associate with anyway, they are not nice people. I have never encountered anyone being snobby about my Mac, in fact we were followed into a quiet cove by a powerboat. We were thinking, "Of all the many places here, why are they following us into this private cove." They guy came over and said, "I saw you out there and wanted to see it up close and ask you some questions. I want to buy a Mac." We've had other "real" sailboats pass us on the water and say "Nice looking boat." When we first launched it, people in the marina said, "Nice boat, how many staterooms does it have?" When you look at how many Macs are out there, there must be more people who like them than trash them.
The first time I saw a mac was in our runabout. We were heading back to the marina and were passing this sailboat under power. It took a long time to overtake them and I thought, "What do they have on the back of that thing?" Later in the marina I saw it was a Honda 50. Wow! This is a fast boat.
Upside:
Inexpensive. You get a lot for your money.
Light weight. Easy to tow without a massive tow vehicle. This makes it easy to get in/out and bring to other locations.
Power. I couldn't take my Hunter through the canal until the current was slack. This made planning the day a chore and stressful. When conditions are bad, we can get back quickly in the Mac. The kids also enjoy being towed in toys. It's so nice to have extra power to fight winds and we have actually towed a power boat that was stranded. It's really nice to get out of something quickly.
Shallow draft. We can go anywhere and right up to the shore and hop off and have a picnic. Exploring landings is as much fun as new waterways.
Easy to sail. Sailing is not rocket science and this boat is pretty easy. Get the lines to the cockpit. This is true for any sailboat.
Trailerability. We are inland and sail on lakes. Being able to bring the boat home is so nice. We leave it in a slip, but we are not held hostage by expensive marina owners for storage. I can bring the boat home and work on it at my house with all my resources. I had to bring all my tools etc. to the marina with the Hunter34. My son also loves to use it as a playhouse with the neighbor kids.
Space. For a 26 foot boat, it has a lot of room. Although the head (bathroom) is small, it's only a 26' boat.
Family fun. There are few boats that a family can have as much fun on. The versatility is what makes this boat great. There is nothing as enjoyable as being at anchor, some flesh grilling on the BBQ, a glass of wine and your Admiral with you as you watch the sunset on the water. Food tastes so much better on the water. Later, watching the stars and the shoreline reflect off the shimmering water. Makes it all worth it. It's not the Hilton, but it's not camping in a tent either.
Downside:
Light weight. This is not an ocean going boat. But few 26 footers are. It gets tossed about easily. High freeboard (waterline to top of the deck) makes it get blown easily. Lack of a keel and high freeboard with light weight makes it hard to dock and get on the trailer in a wind.
Simply crafted. Yes, it's a Clorox bottle. Roger kept costs down by keeping details down. My boat is so beige and it takes some decorating to give it some color. I miss all the fine teak work, but then again, that costs money and many owners have added that themselves.
It's very tender. This freaks the Admiral out when it heals. It stiffens up, but some people can't get used to a boat that leans so easily. I'm also used to a much bigger/heavier boat. It's only a 26' boat.
I researched for a year before buying a new M this year. This forum is a fantastic resource both before and after your purchase. The Mods section is invaluable. I miss my larger boat simply because it's larger, more room etc. However, the Mac is what it is and does it well. If you buy one, make sure to get it in the blue hull which is a lot faster. (wink)
Some more reasons to own a Mac. (Click on the images to enlarge)
Try this in a keel boat. Picnic on the beach.
Back in and hop off for some shady lunch under a tree.
A little bon fire to roast some marshmallows.
